是媒体还是玩家奖，是野鸡还是权威，看看今年是不是和上一年一样没有绝对的赢家

https://gotypicks.blogspot.com/


The Last of Us Part II - 141

The Critics' Picks - 97


The Readers' Picks - 44


Hades - 38

The Critics' Picks - 37


The Readers' Picks - 1




Ghost of Tsushima - 21

The Critics' Picks - 18


The Readers' Picks - 3




Cyberpunk 2077 - 17

The Critics' Picks - 8


The Readers' Picks - 9




Animal Crossing: New Horizons - 15

The Critics' Picks - 15


The Readers' Picks -




Final Fantasy VII Remake - 13

The Critics' Picks - 11


The Readers' Picks - 2



Half-Life: Alyx - 9

Doom Eternal - 8

Microsoft Flight Simulator - 2

Persona 5 Royal - 2

Spiritfarer - 2

Yakuza: Like a Dragon - 2

Assassin's Creed Valhalla - 1


Immortals Fenyx Rising - 1


Marvel's Spider-Man: Miles Morales - 1


Ori and the Will of the Wisps - 1


Sakuna: Of Rice and Ruin - 1


Trusted Reviews (UK) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

EE Pocket-lint Awards (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

Premios Xataka (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

TechTudo (BR) : The Last of Us Part II

TechTudo Readers' Choice (BR) : The Last of Us Part II

TIME (US) : Hades

Golden Joystick Awards (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

Golden Joystick Critics Choice (UK) : Hades

Premios Xataka México (MX) : The Last of Us Part II

Excélsior (MX) : The Last of Us Part II

Paste Magazine (US) : Hades

UAGNA (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Лайфхакер (RU) : The Last of Us Part II

The Washington Post - Launcher (US) : Hades

Slant Magazine (US) : Hades



Evening Standard (UK) : Ghost of Tsushima

Mashable (US) : Hades

Critical Hit (ZA) : Hades

Digital Trends (US) : The Last of Us Part II

BitMe (MX) : The Last of Us Part II

LOS40 México (MX) : Ghost of Tsushima

IGN Japan (JP) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

Complex (US) : Hades

The Game Awards (US) : The Last of Us Part II

The Game Awards Player's Voice (US) : Ghost of Tsushima

Los Angeles Times (US) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Empire Magazine (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

The Blade (US) : Spiritfarer

Vulture (US) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

WhatCulture (UK) : Ghost of Tsushima



Fun & Serious Game Festival (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

Rocket Beans TV - Game Two (DE) : The Last of Us Part II

NME (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

Brazil Game Awards (BR) : The Last of Us Part II

Polygon (US) : Hades

El Mundo (ES) : Hades

VidaExtra (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

WatchMojo (CA) : Cyberpunk 2077

Way Too Many Games (US) : Doom Eternal

C**tech (BR) : The Last of Us Part II

PilatusToday (CH) : Cyberpunk 2077

Checkpoint on JOY 94.9 (AU) : Hades

Game-Debate Global Game Awards (UK) : Assassin's Creed Valhalla

GameSpot (US) : Half-Life: Alyx

But Why Tho? (US) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons



SA Gamer (ZA) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Entertainment Weekly (US) : The Last of Us Part II

Reno Gazette-Journal (US) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

GamerFocus (CO) : Hades

GamerFocus Readers' Choice (CO) : The Last of Us Part II

JeuxVideo-Live (FR) : The Last of Us Part II

GAMINGbible Readers' Choice (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

GINX Esports TV (UK) : Doom Eternal

KGUN 9 (US) : Marvel's Spider-Man: Miles Morales

Red Bull Belgium (BE) : The Last of Us Part II

GameCrate (CA) : The Last of Us Part II

Game-Experience.it (IT) : Doom Eternal

Root-Nation.com (UA) : The Last of Us Part II

FZ (SE) : Half-Life: Alyx

PC Games Readers' Choice (DE) : The Last of Us Part II



Le Soir - Geeko (BE) : Microsoft Flight Simulator

Hardcore Gamer (US) : Ghost of Tsushima

Digitally Downloaded (AU) : Sakuna: Of Rice and Ruin

Gamer.nl (NL) : Hades

Stuff Gadget Awards (UK) : Hades

GamingBolt (US) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

GamesRadar (US) : Hades

IGN (US) : Hades

IGN Readers' Choice (US) : The Last of Us Part II

El Tiempo (CO) : The Last of Us Part II

New Game Plus (AU) : The Last of Us Part II

Den Of Geek (US) : The Last of Us Part II

Den Of Geek Readers' Choice (US) : The Last of Us Part II

RDS Jeux vidéo (CA) : Ghost of Tsushima

VidaExtra Readers' Choice (ES) : The Last of Us Part II



Radiónica (CO) : Ghost of Tsushima

Polityka Magazine (PL) : The Last of Us Part II

DR (DK) : The Last of Us Part II

Gaming Age (US) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

DTF Readers' Choice (RU) : Cyberpunk 2077

3DJuegos México (MX) : The Last of Us Part II

Ars Technica (US) : Hades

CBR (CA) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

El Heraldo de México (MX) : The Last of Us Part II

Tom's Hardware Italy Readers' Choice (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Game Informer (US) : The Last of Us Part II

ActuGaming.net (FR) : Hades

ActuGaming.net Readers' Choice (FR) : The Last of Us Part II

Red Bull España (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

tuttoteK (IT) : The Last of Us Part II



The Guardian (UK) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

National Post - Post Arcade (CA) : The Last of Us Part II

Gameplay Café (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Gameplay Café Readers' Choice (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

GAMINGbible (UK) : Hades

USgamer (US) : Hades

GameRevolution (US) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Bay Area News Group (US) : The Last of Us Part II

Goomba Stomp (CA) : Hades

BR24 (DE) : Cyberpunk 2077

Gamekult Readers' Choice (FR) : Hades

Globo - G1 (BR) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Europe 1 (FR) : The Last of Us Part II

Destructoid (US) : Hades

The Games Machine (IT) : Half-Life: Alyx



Meristation (ES) : Half-Life: Alyx

WellPlayed (AU) : The Last of Us Part II

IGN Hungary (HU) : The Last of Us Part II

IGN India (IN) : Yakuza: Like a Dragon

GameSpace Readers' Choice (US) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

Vandal (ES) : Half-Life: Alyx

Power Unlimited Magazine Readers' Choice (NL) : The Last of Us Part II

Muropaketti (FI) : The Last of Us Part II

Metro - GameCentral (UK) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

MensXP (IN) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

Tom's Guide (US) : The Last of Us Part II

God is a Geek (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

TierraGamer (MX) : The Last of Us Part II

Nerdando.com (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Nerdando.com Readers' Choice (IT) : The Last of Us Part II



Areajugones (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

Busted Readers' Choice (GR) : The Last of Us Part II

IGN Japan Readers' Choice (JP) : Ghost of Tsushima

IGN Italia (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

TechRadar (UK) : Ghost of Tsushima

Geeks and Com' (CA) : The Last of Us Part II

IGN Brasil (BR) : The Last of Us Part II

HVG (HU) : Cyberpunk 2077 and The Last of Us Part II

Gamereactor Suomi (FI) : Ghost of Tsushima

Ajouré-Men Magazine (DE) : Doom Eternal

Power Unlimited Magazine (NL) : The Last of Us Part II

GameInOnline (RU) : Cyberpunk 2077

CQ (RU) : The Last of Us Part II

Insomnia (GR) : The Last of Us Part II

Rocket Chainsaw (AU) : Ghost of Tsushima



M2 Gaming (CA) : The Last of Us Part II

infobae (AR) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Red Bull Polska (PL) : Cyberpunk 2077

GameWorld Readers' Choice (GR) : The Last of Us Part II

Mandatory (US) : Ghost of Tsushima

M3 (SE) : The Last of Us Part II

GameTyrant (US) : The Last of Us Part II

NDTV Gadgets 360 (IN) : Ghost of Tsushima

Inside Games (DE) : Cyberpunk 2077

EL PAÍS (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

XGN (NL) : The Last of Us Part II

Legião dos Heróis (BR) : The Last of Us Part II

Eurogamer.it Readers' Choice (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

GameStar Hungary (HU) : The Last of Us Part II

VGC (UK) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons



Fun Radio (FR) : The Last of Us Part II

Vigiato (IR) : Hades

Vigiato Readers' Choice (IR) : The Last of Us Part II

KeenGamer (CZ) : The Last of Us Part II

Overclockers.ua (UA) : The Last of Us Part II

All Gamers In (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

GameGrin (UK) : Hades

Eurogamer Benelux (NL) : Hades

КГ-Портал Readers' Choice (RU) : Cyberpunk 2077

NRK (NO) : The Last of Us Part II

GameWorld (GR) : The Last of Us Part II

Kotaku Australia Readers' Choice (AU) : The Last of Us Part II

The Telegraph (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

SpazioGames (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

SpazioGames Readers' Choice (IT) : The Last of Us Part II



Atomix (MX) : The Last of Us Part II

Gamereactor España (ES) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

GameStar Hungary Readers' Choice (HU) : The Last of Us Part II

CGMagazine (CA) : Hades

jeuxvideo24 (FR) : Hades

CNews (FR) : The Last of Us Part II

Inverse Readers' Choice (US) : The Last of Us Part II

Gamer365 Readers' Choice (HU) : The Last of Us Part II

PC Guru Magazine Readers' Choice (HU) : Cyberpunk 2077

Men's Enjoy (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Press Start Australia (AU) : The Last of Us Part II

Jeux.ca (CA) : Hades

VentureBeat (US) : Ori and the Will of the Wisps

3DNews Readers' Choice (RU) : The Last of Us Part II

PC World (PL) : Final Fantasy VII Remake



FZ Readers' Choice (SE) : Cyberpunk 2077

Hobby Consolas (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

Eurogamer (UK) : Hades

Stevivor (AU) : Hades

MANIAC.de (DE) : The Last of Us Part II

Gamereactor Portugal (PT) : The Last of Us Part II

Gamereactor Danmark (DK) : Half-Life: Alyx

Gamereactor Sverige (SE) : Microsoft Flight Simulator

Gamereactor Norge (NO) : The Last of Us Part II

Shazoo Readers' Choice (RU) : Cyberpunk 2077

GamerGen (FR) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

4Players (DE) : The Last of Us Part II

4Players Readers' Choice (DE) : The Last of Us Part II

Gamereactor UK (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

Gamereactor France (FR) : The Last of Us Part II



Gamereactor Italia (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Игромания (RU) : Half-Life: Alyx

TheSixthAxis (UK) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

The Digital Fix Readers' Choice (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

JagatPlay (ID) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

HCL Gaming Portal (HR) : Hades

HCL Gaming Portal Readers' Choice (HR) : The Last of Us Part II

PlayGround.ru (RU) : The Last of Us Part II

PlayGround.ru Readers' Choice (RU) : Cyberpunk 2077

Zing.cz Readers' Choice (CZ) : The Last of Us Part II

20 Minutes Readers' Choice (FR) : The Last of Us Part II

El Cultural Magazine (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

Shacknews (US) : Half-Life: Alyx

Presse-citron (FR) : The Last of Us Part II

JVFrance (FR) : Ghost of Tsushima



Gizmodo en Español (ES) : Hades

IGN Benelux Readers' Choice (NL) : The Last of Us Part II

GameMAG (RU) : Ghost of Tsushima

Varvat (SE) : The Last of Us Part II

RespawnPoint.cz (CZ) : Immortals Fenyx Rising

DarkZero (UK) : Doom Eternal

Eurogamer Readers' Choice (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

SmashPad (US) : Ghost of Tsushima

Game Legends Readers' Choice (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Eurogamer.pt Readers' Choice (PT) : The Last of Us Part II

Eurogamer.de Readers' Choice (DE) : The Last of Us Part II

GameVicio (BR) : Doom Eternal

GameVicio Readers' Choice (BR) : The Last of Us Part II

Gameswelt (DE) : The Last of Us Part II

COGconnected (CA) : Ghost of Tsushima



EGM (US) : The Last of Us Part II

Serial Gamer (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Game Channel (HU) : The Last of Us Part II

Siliconera (US) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

3DNews (RU) : Hades

REWIND.sk (SK) : The Last of Us Part II

SomHráč.sk (SK) : The Last of Us Part II

JeuxActu (FR) : The Last of Us Part II

3DJuegos (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

Lega Nerd (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

SweClockers.com Readers' Choice (SE) : Cyberpunk 2077

Unboxholics Readers' Choice (GR) : The Last of Us Part II

WorthPlaying (US) : Hades

GRY OnLine (PL) : Cyberpunk 2077

Geeky (AR) : The Last of Us Part II



Cubiq (RU) : Half-Life: Alyx

Movies Room (PL) : Doom Eternal

Aktuality.sk - HernáZóna (SK) : Ghost of Tsushima

DualShockers (US) : Hades

DualShockers Readers' Choice (US) : The Last of Us Part II

IGN India Readers' Choice (IN) : Cyberpunk 2077

Metacritic (US) : Persona 5 Royal

Spill.no (NO) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

IGN Middle East (AE) : Ghost of Tsushima

IGN Middle East Readers' Choice (AE) : The Last of Us Part II

Game*Spark Readers' Choice (JP) : Ghost of Tsushima

Everyeye.it (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Everyeye.it Readers' Choice (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Next Gen Base (UK) : The Last of Us Part II

SomHráč.sk Readers' Choice (SK) : The Last of Us Part II



Goodgame.hr Readers' Choice (HR) : The Last of Us Part II

Cybersport.ru (RU) : Yakuza: Like a Dragon

Cybersport.ru Readers' Choice (RU) : The Last of Us Part II

Gamerweb (PL) : Doom Eternal

iDNES.cz - BonusWeb Readers' Choice (CZ) : Cyberpunk 2077

DTF (RU) : The Last of Us Part II

Multiplayer.it (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Multiplayer.it Readers' Choice (IT) : The Last of Us Part II

Unwinnable (US) : Hades

Zero Punctuation (US) : Spiritfarer

GameFAQs (US) : Final Fantasy VII Remake

PPE.pl (PL) : The Last of Us Part II

3DJuegos Readers' Choice (ES) : The Last of Us Part II

GreatGamer.Ru (RU) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

Explosion Network (AU) : Hades



GameRevolution Readers' Choice (US) : The Last of Us Part II

Geek Culture (SG) : Ghost of Tsushima

NoobFeed (US) : Persona 5 Royal

Games.cz (CZ) : Animal Crossing: New Horizons

一堆The Last of Us Part II

The Blade不错不错

IGN给了哈迪斯
看来今年还是比较多元化，很可能最后TLOU2和哈迪斯差不多，讽刺的是TLOU2拿了一堆读者选择奖233

hades这玩意到底强在哪里，一堆媒体这么看重。
就因为roguelike里加了叙事？

你上手玩就知道了，这东西和我以前玩过的肉鸽都不太一样

我玩了呀，
算roguelike不如以撒、枪牢
算indie不如去年baba、迪斯科、outer wilds，
就算同工作室，我也更喜欢晶体管。

从销量来看 我觉得读者投票都是看热闹不嫌事大

其实TLOU2除了有一个首发400万的数据外是没有任何新的官方数据的，销量到底什么样也不知道
以TLOU初代来说，600万的销量数据是在游戏发售一年后才宣布的，18年战神，首发310万销量后，也是在一年后的5月才第二次官方说销量破一千万的，所以TLOU2销量如何大致明年六七月份时会有个定论
看不少人说因为TLOU2卖得差所以SIE不敢公布销量，其实SIE软件数据放出一直都是这么个节奏

感觉没啥意义，完全取决于收集者

之前还看到过另一个收集goty网站的数据，每年数字差别挺大的

对马岛数据更新的很勤快啊……

还是不能理解hades到底是凭什么

对马岛是真的惨，完全后妈生的。
SuckerPunch有这么不受自家待见的么，
外面投票要被大前辈嘲讽，
自家投票索妈也不待见。

TLOU2暴死是不可能的 估计卖的比1多 但肯定是低于他们自己的预期了
索尼至少预期是千万没跑的

哈迪斯我也经常会上去刷刷，但我感觉这游戏又短又肝，不改资源要刷的东西太多，boss少，场景少，虽然美术风格优秀，但仍然是一个中小体量的独立游戏，能拿那么多GOTA真是不理解

哪儿勤快了？官方数据只有首发3天240万，难道还有别的官方数据？官方公布的节奏一直是这样的。再举个例子地平线，官方数据分别是两周260万，一年760万，两年破千万。
唯一一个公布比较勤的可能是蜘蛛侠，因为卖的确实很好，还赶上年底爆发

游戏完成度和本身硬素质摆着的，和美末2比起来，原先预想中能打的那个跳到明年还要面临波兰诉讼
对马岛是今年最大黑马，作为一个创意拔尖的缝合兽完成度也是很高，就可惜投资体量的问题，重复内容很多，大部分东西中规中矩，还是比不过美末2.

老话题了，独立游戏里哈迪斯出不出挑？独立游戏配不配得奖，

tlou2销量被动森吊打是没得跑了

去问问国内实体商人手里的盘多少钱 就知道这游戏卖的好不好了

我觉得不够，Hades的优点和一些3A游戏很相似，就是更Polished，反而作为独立游戏来说拿奖是不合格的。

问题是国内PS4游戏的行情对于TLOU2的销量有多大的参考意义，国内盘贵的话就证明游戏卖的好那FF7R岂不是冤枉死233

肉鸽这种迭代多年且商业目的强烈的玩法，如果只是完成度高，本质上和同类别其他阿猫阿狗没有任何区别，在哪一个宇宙都不配拿到85以上的分数
事实上，肉鸽发展到今天，其概念完全是背弃了独立游戏的精神内核，却总是在独立名头下抢占其他更有独创性的游戏的生存空间，曾经做出过晶体管这样的游戏，结果转头凭借哈迪斯大获成功，我觉得很可笑

hades可是今年oc评分第一啊。

你们是怎么理解独立游戏定义的，独立的意思原来不是指经济独立，而是特立独行和主流不一样吗？

哈迪斯好像有ns版没有ps4版？

在独立游戏里还真不出挑，今年纯属矮子里拔高个。

Hades的内容释放、在Roguelite下兼顾爽快度、拆开的困难模式和包装过的简单模式等都做得颇有特色，加上音画素质都强、角色剧情观感好，在没啥惊艳indie的情况下拿点年度也算情理之中。而且虽然许多人更喜欢晶体管，但连制作组自己都说这次才是真·集大成之作。
反观Ori2也是尝试集大成，就显得比较拉胯。（虽然不是独立但这里说的GOTY）

凭立绘好看吧（我是很喜欢这个立绘就是了虽然云游玩流程的时候没感觉出特别突出让人跃跃欲试的冲动）

更新下，目前看媒体成分大部分我比较熟悉的老面孔给了哈迪斯，TLOU2想当年神海4一样少量的老面孔和很多读者奖，下面就看DICE和GDC会给谁了，感觉HADES赢面大一些